2021 Dodge Charger or Nissan Maxima? Pros and Cons Review

Though the Dodge Charger and Nissan Maxima undertake the same kind issue, these full-size sedans go about their enterprise in very other ways. The Maxima takes a extra luxurious method to its options and appointments whereas nonetheless attempting to be enjoyable to drive. In the meantime, the Charger emphasizes energy and efficiency greater than consolation or know-how.

Deciding between the Charger and Maxima? Listed below are the professionals and cons of every to contemplate.

2021 Dodge Charger: Execs Over the Maxima

Engine Selections

Each the Maxima and Charger come customary with a V-6 engine. Within the Nissan, it’s a 3.5-liter unit that makes 300 hp and 261 lb-ft of torque, all of which is distributed to the entrance wheels through a constantly variable computerized transmission (CVT). The Dodge has a 3.6-liter mill that seems 292–300 hp and 260–264 lb-ft. Energy is routed by way of an eight-speed computerized, and patrons can select both rear-wheel- or all-wheel-drive.

That’s as thrilling because it will get within the Maxima, however the enjoyable has solely simply begun within the Charger—it’s additionally supplied with a number of V-Eight selections. These vary from a 370-hp 5.7-liter Hemi to the notorious 797-hp supercharged 6.2-liter powerplant within the Hellcat Redeye. Certainly, the Maxima’s V-6 offers affordable acceleration. However for the power-hungry, a V-8-equipped Charger is the one selection right here.

Passenger and Cargo House

The Charger and Maxima commerce benefits in inside capacities. Entrance-row headroom measures 38.6 inches within the Charger and 39.four inches within the Maxima. Likewise, there’s much less entrance legroom within the Dodge, which has 41.Eight inches to the Nissan’s enormous 45.Zero inches. Within the Charger’s second row, headroom is 36.6 inches, negligibly lower than the Maxima’s 36.7 inches. Nevertheless, back-seat legroom measures 40.1 inches within the Charger, way more than the Maxima’s 34.2 inches. Moreover, the Charger’s trunk is larger, with 16.5 cubic toes to the Maxima’s 14.3. Lengthy-legged drivers will respect the Maxima’s beneficiant front-row area. However for the reason that Charger remains to be fairly roomy up entrance and way more so within the second row, to not point out it has a bigger trunk, it looks like the higher general package deal for spacious sedan practicality.

Colours and Trims

Apart from black, white, and silver, the Maxima is offered in eye-catching blue, orange, or crimson paint. We like that Nissan provides greater than drab primary colours, however the enjoyable ones can be found solely on sure trims and price $395 additional. The Charger has a spread of superior paint selections. Positive, you may get black, white, or varied grays, however you even have two blues, two reds, two oranges, and extra to select from—try the stylish F8 inexperienced or the delicate Hellraisin purple. All of those paints can be found on every Charger trim level and price the identical quantity: $0.00. V-8-powered Chargers additionally provide a spread of retro-tastic stripe and decal packages and a muscular widebody kit. The Maxima looks good, however if you would like a automobile you can personalize with stand-out type, the Charger provides you essentially the most choices.


IntelliChoice, a MotorTrend subsidiary, works to find out automobile values by calculating long-term possession prices. Between the Charger and Maxima, there’s a transparent winner—with caveats. The Maxima is rated as a Poor worth; insurance coverage prices and depreciation undermine its long-term outlook. In the meantime, the Charger lineup is rated as an Common worth, however values for particular trims range. For instance, the essential SXT V-6 mannequin is a Good worth, because it shouldn’t value an enormous quantity to run, insure, or restore. However selecting a V-Eight Charger lessens the worth equation. An R/T is an Common worth, however the Hellcat is rated as Poor. Why? Nicely, IntelliChoice estimates that it’ll value some $90,000 over 5 years, with over a 3rd of that being depreciation and almost $15,000 of it pumped into the gas tank. Even nonetheless, the Charger has a worth benefit over the Maxima—simply know that it relies on which mannequin you get.

2021 Nissan Maxima: Execs Over the Charger

Inside Design and Supplies

Once you pay for a high-end Charger, your {dollars} go towards what’s underneath the hood greater than contained in the cabin. Apart from particulars reminiscent of carbon-fiber trim and Alcantara upholstery, costly Chargers share appointments with bare-bones rental lot specials. It’s the other case with the Maxima. All fashions have the identical engine, so choosing the next trim degree makes issues nicer inside. Quilted leather-based upholstery, a rear window sunshade, and multi-color ambient lighting are among the many niceties added as you progress up the Maxima trim stroll. We expect its cabin design is extra aesthetically pleasing, too.

Security and Driver Help Options

If security is a precedence, the Maxima is the higher selection. From the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), the 2020 Maxima earns five-star rankings throughout the board (a whole set of rankings for the 2021 mannequin hasn’t been revealed). The 2021 Charger will get a four-star frontal crash rating and 5 stars in different classes. From the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), the Maxima acquired the 2020 High Security Choose + designation, an accolade the Charger can’t match. Within the driver’s side small overlap front crash test, which replicates what occurs when the entrance left nook of a automobile hits an object at 40 mph, the Dodge acquired the second-lowest Marginal rating. Additionally, its headlights acquired the bottom Poor rating.

All Maxima trims are customary geared up with adaptive cruise management, lane-keep help, blind-spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert, entrance and rear computerized braking, and extra driver-assist options. The Charger comes with none of those. You may add them by selecting choice packages, however the Hellcat isn’t appropriate with options reminiscent of adaptive cruise management.

Gas Economic system and Driving Vary

Gas economic system rankings from the Environmental Safety Company (EPA) for the 2021 Maxima are 20/30 mpg metropolis/freeway, barely higher than the V-6 Charger’s 19/30 mpg ranking. The Maxima has an 18-gallon gas tank, which offers a theoretical most vary of 540 miles. Nevertheless, the Charger’s tank holds 18.5 gallons, permitting as much as 555 miles of cruising distance. This all goes out the tailpipe in case you select a V-Eight Charger. Its most economical eight-pot is the 5.7-liter Hemi, which is rated at 16/25 mpg and might cowl about 460 miles between fill-ups. In the meantime, the Hellcat chugs premium gas at 12/21 mpg for underneath 390 miles of driving vary, assuming you’re light on the throttle—yeah, proper.

Freeway Cruising

As we came upon throughout its 12 months in our long-term fleet, the Maxima is a capable freeway cruiser. Its driver-assist options and cozy trip make it a calming automobile to hit the street in, whether or not for on a regular basis commutes or multi-state journeys. Though V-6 Chargers are additionally spacious and cozy, the fashions’ absence of ordinary driver-assist tech makes taking to the street that rather more taxing. V-Eight Charger fashions characteristic sportier chassis setups, which enhance dealing with however diminish outright consolation. These bigger engines additionally necessitate extra frequent stops for gas. The Charger is perhaps higher enjoyable on a twisty street, however the Maxima is nicer for regular driving.

The Verdict



The Maxima is a greater wager than a Charger in case you’re in search of a wise, comfy full-size sedan. Its nicer inside and quite a few driver-assist options make it extra luxurious, and its robust security scores and respectable gas economic system earn it pragmatic factors. Nevertheless, in case you’re after a thrill trip, the Charger is the one selection right here. When geared up with a V-Eight engine, it’s a correct muscle automobile, offering extra energy, noise, and tire smoke than any competitor can.

2021 Dodge Charger Execs Over Nissan Maxima

  • V-Eight engine selections
  • Extra passenger and cargo area
  • Enjoyable shade and trim choices
  • Higher worth

2021 Nissan Maxima Execs Over Dodge Charger

  • Higher gas economic system
  • Nicer inside
  • Normal security and driver-assist tech
  • A extra comfy freeway cruiser

The put up 2021 Dodge Charger or Nissan Maxima? Pros and Cons Review appeared first on MotorTrend.

Source link